BMW X3 Forum
BMW X3 Forum
Welcome to the ultimate G45 BMW X3 community.
BMW Garage BMW Meets Register Today's Posts
Post Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread
      07-09-2015, 12:52 PM   #265
KingOfJericho
Major General
KingOfJericho's Avatar
United_States
2458
Rep
7,341
Posts

Drives: Yes
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: CT

iTrader: (1)

Garage List
2010 135i Coupe  [5.26]
I'm currently driving my first Auto ever and while I appreciate it on my commutes to and from midtown Manhattan, I loathe it in just about every other aspect. I just don't feel like I'm controlling the car.
__________________
The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Bimmerpost.

2018 Jeep Grand Cherokee High Altitude Hemi | 2010 S4 Sold | 2010 BMW 135i Retired | 2006 Lotus Exige Sold
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 01:34 PM   #266
....,,,,..,,..
General
No_Country
6626
Rep
20,651
Posts

Drives: xxxx
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: xxxx

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by KingOfJericho View Post
I'm currently driving my first Auto ever and while I appreciate it on my commutes to and from midtown Manhattan, I loathe it in just about every other aspect. I just don't feel like I'm controlling the car.
Drove a few hundred miles today, back roads.

Stick to the left and sports selected, drove in full manual mode, changing when I felt like it, including a few accidental red line moments lol.

Car is very responsive in manual sports mode on the paddles and love the ability to drop a number of gears in one go, with my hands on the wheel and road just over width of the car
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 02:58 PM   #267
JasonCSU
Colonel
United_States
705
Rep
2,548
Posts

Drives: '08 135i, '88 325is
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Denver, CO

iTrader: (0)

Garage List
1988 BMW 325is  [0.00]
2008 BMW 135i  [0.00]
Quote:
Originally Posted by captainaudio View Post
I think many here need to learn the concept of "In my opinion" and "I prefer".

How does anyone here know what someone else considers fun or tedious?

Yet these opinions are frequently put forth here as if they were statements of fact.

I completely agree. It doesn't bother me one bit that some people prefer to have the DCT. What does bother me is that some people think the DCT should be forced upon everyone. What is the issue with having choices?
__________________
Delivered in Munich, broken in on the Nurburgring.
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 03:01 PM   #268
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

If you want to control the gear you are in put the AT or DCT in manual and use the paddles or the lever to shift.

If you feel that using a clutch pedal is more fun or makes you feel more involved that is a perfectly legitimate opinion. As for at MT giving more control - I don't buy it.
__________________

Drivers Club at Lime Rock - International Motorsports Research Center - Society of Automotive Historians - Madison Avenue Sports Car Driving and Chowder Society (0nly a VP) - BMWCCA - Porsche Club of America - M Gruppe - Polish Race Drivers of America (PDRA) - Glen Club (Watkins Glen International) - Jaguar Club of Southern New England
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 03:05 PM   #269
Fundguy1
Major General
Fundguy1's Avatar
2043
Rep
8,339
Posts

Drives: 335 e93
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Orlando, fl

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by captainaudio View Post
If you want to control the gear you are in put the AT or DCT in manual and use the paddled or the lever to shift.

If you feel that using a clutch pedal is more fun or makes you feel more involved that is a perfectly legitimate opinion. As for at MT giving more control - I don't buy it.
Done that. Still shifts for you when you don't want to. Doesn't downshift enough usually too. Etc. Pita. I've tried them all. Too unpredictable. I hate flappy paddles.
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 03:32 PM   #270
vohit4rohit
New Member
United_States
2
Rep
5
Posts

Drives: 2007 328i 6 spd
Join Date: Jul 2015
Location: Los Angeles, CA

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by KingOfJericho View Post
I guess when they start offering food in pill form, you'll be the first to jump on board because chewing, tasting, and reveling in the flavor is sooooooo 2015 and pills are simply faster.
bravo. for most of us here in this forum, driving isn't about how fast you can get from point A to point B. it's about the journey there. and we want that journey to continue to be as fun and in our control as possible.
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 04:39 PM   #271
....,,,,..,,..
General
No_Country
6626
Rep
20,651
Posts

Drives: xxxx
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: xxxx

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fundguy1 View Post
Done that. Still shifts for you when you don't want to. Doesn't downshift enough usually too. Etc. Pita. I've tried them all. Too unpredictable. I hate flappy paddles.
Never had it change on me when in manual, today even had it red line by accident, no change.

It's simple to drop a few gears in one go with the paddles.

Having drove manual for over 30 years, the 8AT can be tricky for some, as it takes more skill and learning than a manual to get the best out of it.
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 04:49 PM   #272
stefan
Brigadier General
stefan's Avatar
No_Country
2375
Rep
4,258
Posts

Drives: M2 Comp
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: North

iTrader: (2)

Such a ridiculous debate. There is NO manual mode on a DCT. It's still an auto box and you tell it what to do via computers. This is fast but it has no feel whatsoever.

I guess I have to admit I'm not a race car driver like most DCT enthusiasts, and I'm not concerned with a few extra seconds. I just want driving feel. BMW left that all behind in the new models with EPS, turbo, and now finally the death of the manual.

One thing I'd like to know is how many owners just bought DCT because they don't know how to drive manual. I imagine that's a non trivial percentage of sales. People aren't teaching their kids manual, and their kids grow up only having an auto. Therefore less sales of manual. Perhaps.
__________________
///M Power
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 05:49 PM   #273
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Fundguy1 View Post
Done that. Still shifts for you when you don't want to. Doesn't downshift enough usually too. Etc. Pita. I've tried them all. Too unpredictable. I hate flappy paddles.
"Doing that" and doing that correctly are two very different things.

If the DCT shifts for you it is because you are doing something stupid and in some cases it wont shift when you do. The Steptronic in my 335i would upshift at red line in manual mode. The DCT in my M4 will not.
__________________

Drivers Club at Lime Rock - International Motorsports Research Center - Society of Automotive Historians - Madison Avenue Sports Car Driving and Chowder Society (0nly a VP) - BMWCCA - Porsche Club of America - M Gruppe - Polish Race Drivers of America (PDRA) - Glen Club (Watkins Glen International) - Jaguar Club of Southern New England

Last edited by captainaudio; 07-09-2015 at 06:07 PM..
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 05:54 PM   #274
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stefan View Post
Such a ridiculous debate. There is NO manual mode on a DCT. It's still an auto box and you tell it what to do via computers. This is fast but it has no feel whatsoever.

I guess I have to admit I'm not a race car driver like most DCT enthusiasts, and I'm not concerned with a few extra seconds. I just want driving feel. BMW left that all behind in the new models with EPS, turbo, and now finally the death of the manual.

One thing I'd like to know is how many owners just bought DCT because they don't know how to drive manual. I imagine that's a non trivial percentage of sales. People aren't teaching their kids manual, and their kids grow up only having an auto. Therefore less sales of manual. Perhaps.
In the words of the late legendary race driver and automotive journalist Denise McCLuggage "Drive what you're in". A good driver adapts to the car and adjusts driving style accoringly. You don't drive a RWD car the same way you drive an AWD car or a FWD car. You don't drive a rear or mid engine car the same way you drive a front engine car, In the hands of an expert driver any of these can perform very well.


Although I sure there are drivers of DCTs who don't know how to drive an MT
I personally don't know anyone who own a DCT car that can not drive a manual and the vast majority of them are very proficient with an MT. I also think that if you do not have experience with an MT and have never had to shift gears it is more difficult to understand and exploit the capabilities of a paddle shifted transmission.

And what percentage of MT drivers are not particularly adept at driving MTs? My experience with high performance driving schools has shown me that it is surprisingly high. They may be able to smoothly start from a stop and get from one gear to another but many have no idea how to heel and toe or even rev match a downshift. In many cases they spend a lot of time in the wrong gear. Knowing how to operate a clutch pedal does not make you Juan Pablo Montoya.
__________________

Drivers Club at Lime Rock - International Motorsports Research Center - Society of Automotive Historians - Madison Avenue Sports Car Driving and Chowder Society (0nly a VP) - BMWCCA - Porsche Club of America - M Gruppe - Polish Race Drivers of America (PDRA) - Glen Club (Watkins Glen International) - Jaguar Club of Southern New England

Last edited by captainaudio; 07-09-2015 at 06:16 PM..
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 06:18 PM   #275
....,,,,..,,..
General
No_Country
6626
Rep
20,651
Posts

Drives: xxxx
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: xxxx

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stefan View Post
Such a ridiculous debate. There is NO manual mode on a DCT. It's still an auto box and you tell it what to do via computers. This is fast but it has no feel whatsoever.

I guess I have to admit I'm not a race car driver like most DCT enthusiasts, and I'm not concerned with a few extra seconds. I just want driving feel. BMW left that all behind in the new models with EPS, turbo, and now finally the death of the manual.

One thing I'd like to know is how many owners just bought DCT because they don't know how to drive manual. I imagine that's a non trivial percentage of sales. People aren't teaching their kids manual, and their kids grow up only having an auto. Therefore less sales of manual. Perhaps.

Try asking the UK bit of the forum on their view of the 8AT.

Remember this is a country where around 95/98% of drivers drive a manual.

Also where the driving test lets you drive manual and auto, however if you do an auto driving test you cannot drive a manual - against the law!

Around 98% of drivers learn to drive in a manual.

75% of cars bought last year where manual.


The 8AT is a different calibre to the old type auto.


It's amazing how many people seem to be driving gods with a manual car on here.

It's nothing special, pretty much our entire driving population drive manual without fuss.
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 06:36 PM   #276
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Brigand
Quote:
Originally Posted by stefan View Post
Such a ridiculous debate. There is NO manual mode on a DCT. It's still an auto box and you tell it what to do via computers. This is fast but it has no feel whatsoever.

I guess I have to admit I'm not a race car driver like most DCT enthusiasts, and I'm not concerned with a few extra seconds. I just want driving feel. BMW left that all behind in the new models with EPS, turbo, and now finally the death of the manual.

One thing I'd like to know is how many owners just bought DCT because they don't know how to drive manual. I imagine that's a non trivial percentage of sales. People aren't teaching their kids manual, and their kids grow up only having an auto. Therefore less sales of manual. Perhaps.

Try asking the UK bit of the forum on their view of the 8AT.

Remember this is a country where around 95/98% of drivers drive a manual.

Also where the driving test lets you drive manual and auto, however if you do an auto driving test you cannot drive a manual - against the law!

Around 98% of drivers learn to drive in a manual.

75% of cars bought last year where manual.


The 8AT is a different calibre to the old type auto.


It's amazing how many people seem to be driving gods with a manual car on here.

It's nothing special, pretty much our entire driving population drive manual without fuss.
I was involved in a conversation with a group of professional drivers at an event I attended recently. These were guys who have raced (and won) at LeMans, Sebring, Daytona and the Indy 500 and a few of them competed in Formula 1. Several of them were national champions in various race series and most of them are currently employed testing cars for manufacturers and auto magazines.

I asked one of them (who happened to be the Senior Skip Barber Instructor who helped me learn how to heel and toe and double clutch) how he liked the DCT in the E92 M3 he drives. His answer was "It shifts better than I can".

There was a general consensus that MTs were enjoyable and involving but when I brought up the issue of control not one of them felt that an MT gave more control than a paddle shifted transmission.

I had a similar conversation with one of the drivers from team RLL whose personal car is an E92 M3 with DCT,

I tend to give the opinions of these pros more weight than the opinions of random posters on an Internet forum.
__________________

Drivers Club at Lime Rock - International Motorsports Research Center - Society of Automotive Historians - Madison Avenue Sports Car Driving and Chowder Society (0nly a VP) - BMWCCA - Porsche Club of America - M Gruppe - Polish Race Drivers of America (PDRA) - Glen Club (Watkins Glen International) - Jaguar Club of Southern New England
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 07:12 PM   #277
C5 FOR
First Lieutenant
172
Rep
378
Posts

Drives: G05 xDrive30d Mineral White
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: Edinburgh

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by B-1Pilot
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fundguy1
Quote:
Originally Posted by B-1Pilot View Post
I just wish all these MT guys would go back to sending letters through the mail -- its way more rewarding, anyways -- and get off our technologically advanced internet

For the people who think the P-car GT4 is a manual because of performance you are way wrong. It is about a business decision to reduce it's performance. If you don't understand this, you don't understand the automotive business. You probably also don't understand that the M5/M6 is the BMW apex car for performance, not the M3 or M4, and always has been. In the business sense, and in very typical German fashion, the lesser car (in price) will not exceed the performance capabilities of the higher one. There will always be a performance progression from 1M -> M2-> M3/4 -> M5/M6.

Similarly, the only way manual stays around is if the take rates make it economically feasible for BMW to continue building them.

For who was asking on the MT vs DCT take rates --

E9X M3s in US, take rate was about 45% Manual
E60 M5 and E63 M6 in US, take rate was about 15% which is why it was dropped for the F10/F12

i dont know what the F80 take rate is currently, but if its anywhere above I would say 30% they should offer a manual for the M2. If they are going to do more than a limited run, they will have to do a DCT of some sort as well...
Scott's post above confirms that market demand for MT in the M2/3/4 will keep it alive for at least another generation.. I suspect if the Fxx and Gxx take rates work out to be high enough they will continue making MTs for the customers that want them.

Why we keep getting our collective panties in a twist on this before the unveil of the M2 is beside me -- its gonna have an MT variant, the real question is whether its going to be a ZF AT or an M-DCT as well.
I'm curious Why do you or anyone else want to kill the manual? It's not stopping you from having your silly computer do your shifting at exactly the wrong time or not downshifting enough etc. You still have your crappy boring obtrusive dct. We just don't want the jot of driving sucked out of our lives. I guess if it isn't the way you like it shouldn't exist. Guess any car that isn't just like yours shouldn't exist either

As for rates and business sense, if BMW wants to kill the manual, of the 45% who bought them. More than half would probably go elsewhere. If BM W thinks loosing 25% of its sales is cheaper than offering the manual, have at it. Manual sales for corvettes and hellcats will spike I'm sure.
Why do you think I want to kill the manual? I just want the M-DCT; I couldn't care less what any of you buy.... However the constant inference that manual is better or that manual drivers are better is what bothers me. As a BMW stockholder, I also understand why MTs are not a priority, because they are not necessarily the most profitable.

FWIW... I operate a $300 million high performance vehicle for a living...technology always trumps nostalgia for performance.

Finally, can you spots the two MTs in my driveway?

You sir are an arse!

Perhaps even an arrogant one!
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 07:23 PM   #278
Dan Bilzerian
Major
Dan Bilzerian's Avatar
356
Rep
1,195
Posts

Drives: E90 325i 6MT
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: Edmonds,WA

iTrader: (0)

The Porsche and the Bike.
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 08:48 PM   #279
C5driver
Major
C5driver's Avatar
3492
Rep
1,125
Posts

Drives: 55...just kidding.
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: 33.6167° N, 117.8975° W

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by stefan
One thing I'd like to know is how many owners just bought DCT because they don't know how to drive manual.
I bought a DCT because my weekend toy is a 6MT. Sample of one, but you asked.
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 09:35 PM   #280
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by C5driver View Post
I bought a DCT because my weekend toy is a 6MT. Sample of one, but you asked.
Make that a sample of 2

I have owned a variety of cars over the years, some with ATs, most with MTs and now one with a DCT.

For some of them an MT was the logical choice or in some cases the only choice (1969 Firebird 400, Spec Miata, 1960 Mini Cooper S, 1954 Jaguar XK120, 1959 Austin Healy "Bug Eye" Sprite, Honda Accord and Acura Integra. I had an Audi 100LS and a Lexus SC300 with MTs.

For other cars an AT was my choice and again in some cases the only choice (BMW 750Lix. Jaguar XJ, Jaguar XKR, BMW 335i E93).

I even had a Saab 95 wagon with a three cylinder, two cycle engine with a four speed on the column and centrifugal clutch freewheeling. It had a rack for a case of the oil that had to be added to the gasoline under the seat. In freewheel mode you did not need to use the third pedal that operated a conventional clutch to shift gears. Just let off on the gas and let the centrifugal clutch decouple, shift and get back on the gas. On my Honda Accords and Acura Integra I used to shift without using the clutch quite often. The Honda 5 Speed MTs were great transmissions and would effortless slip into gear.

My wife drove many of those cars and was very at good driving MTs.

I now regularly switch from AT/DCT to MT and I can honestly say that after years of driving MTs I do not find it particularly challenging although I have to admit that there is a certain satisfaction to a perfectly executed heel and toe double clutched downshift.

In any case I hope BMW continues to offer MTs. If it was not for the auto rev match feature which I absolutely hated when I test drove one I would have seriously considered an MT M4.
__________________

Drivers Club at Lime Rock - International Motorsports Research Center - Society of Automotive Historians - Madison Avenue Sports Car Driving and Chowder Society (0nly a VP) - BMWCCA - Porsche Club of America - M Gruppe - Polish Race Drivers of America (PDRA) - Glen Club (Watkins Glen International) - Jaguar Club of Southern New England

Last edited by captainaudio; 07-09-2015 at 10:22 PM..
Appreciate 1
      07-09-2015, 10:21 PM   #281
B-1Pilot
Yankee Air Pirate
B-1Pilot's Avatar
United_States
173
Rep
987
Posts

Drives: M5
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: The Nation's Capitol

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by C5 FOR
Quote:
Originally Posted by B-1Pilot
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fundguy1
Quote:
Originally Posted by B-1Pilot View Post
I just wish all these MT guys would go back to sending letters through the mail -- its way more rewarding, anyways -- and get off our technologically advanced internet

For the people who think the P-car GT4 is a manual because of performance you are way wrong. It is about a business decision to reduce it's performance. If you don't understand this, you don't understand the automotive business. You probably also don't understand that the M5/M6 is the BMW apex car for performance, not the M3 or M4, and always has been. In the business sense, and in very typical German fashion, the lesser car (in price) will not exceed the performance capabilities of the higher one. There will always be a performance progression from 1M -> M2-> M3/4 -> M5/M6.

Similarly, the only way manual stays around is if the take rates make it economically feasible for BMW to continue building them.

For who was asking on the MT vs DCT take rates --

E9X M3s in US, take rate was about 45% Manual
E60 M5 and E63 M6 in US, take rate was about 15% which is why it was dropped for the F10/F12

i dont know what the F80 take rate is currently, but if its anywhere above I would say 30% they should offer a manual for the M2. If they are going to do more than a limited run, they will have to do a DCT of some sort as well...
Scott's post above confirms that market demand for MT in the M2/3/4 will keep it alive for at least another generation.. I suspect if the Fxx and Gxx take rates work out to be high enough they will continue making MTs for the customers that want them.

Why we keep getting our collective panties in a twist on this before the unveil of the M2 is beside me -- its gonna have an MT variant, the real question is whether its going to be a ZF AT or an M-DCT as well.
I'm curious Why do you or anyone else want to kill the manual? It's not stopping you from having your silly computer do your shifting at exactly the wrong time or not downshifting enough etc. You still have your crappy boring obtrusive dct. We just don't want the jot of driving sucked out of our lives. I guess if it isn't the way you like it shouldn't exist. Guess any car that isn't just like yours shouldn't exist either

As for rates and business sense, if BMW wants to kill the manual, of the 45% who bought them. More than half would probably go elsewhere. If BM W thinks loosing 25% of its sales is cheaper than offering the manual, have at it. Manual sales for corvettes and hellcats will spike I'm sure.
Why do you think I want to kill the manual? I just want the M-DCT; I couldn't care less what any of you buy.... However the constant inference that manual is better or that manual drivers are better is what bothers me. As a BMW stockholder, I also understand why MTs are not a priority, because they are not necessarily the most profitable.

FWIW... I operate a $300 million high performance vehicle for a living...technology always trumps nostalgia for performance.

Finally, can you spots the two MTs in my driveway?

[img]
View post on imgur.com
[/IMG]
You sir are an arse!

Perhaps even an arrogant one!
Sorry if i came off that way... Probably you are seeing my smart asserted after the evolution of a LOT of these threads over the years... My point was meant to be simple... I have 4 different trannys and I enjoy them all. I loathe the inference that those who choose a DCT are all people who either can't drive a stick, or aren't enthusiast enough, or don't like to have fun driving. I am a vehicular adrenaline junky, and want the peak performance... That exists in BMW via the DCT. There are a lot of people on this forum who slam the DCT without ever driving it, thinking it's the same as the 8AT. I meant to show that I have experience with multiple trannys I like, and my opinion and preference for my next fun car is the DCT.
__________________
deposit placed for 2025 G99 ///M5 Touring || 2020 F90///M5 || 2014 F10 ///M5 || My Epic ED trip report|| || 2009 BMW R1200RT
Appreciate 0
      07-09-2015, 10:46 PM   #282
Bbb34
Major
Canada
731
Rep
1,472
Posts

Drives: '11 535i 6sp. DHP/RWD
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: ON

iTrader: (0)

I find lots of people are confusing performance and driving "feel".

It really boils down to what you like.
If you love driving manual, it's very difficult to find replacement, and to me personally performance comes secondary. Satisfying feeling I personally get from driving manual, feeling of control, having to pay attention to what I'm doing all the time is very rewarding. So far I was unable to find experience that's as rewarding and satisfying with automatic transmission.

Granted, lots of progress has been made, there are some trully amazing automatic transmissions out there. Better gas mileage, faster 0-60, up and down sifts that are quicker than ever thought possible. Still for those of us who love manuals, it's simply not the same.

My money will follow manual transmission, as difficult as this might be in the future. As long as I can find one, that's what I'm buying.

I'll just ask this though. Having recently driven with very young, new grad. co-worker in her first ever car, Golf GTI with automatic transmission.

Does anybody here think that young drivers would be that much better, initially and years down the road, if only they were forced to learn driving and obtain their license with manual transmission (as it was the case when I was "oh-so-young")???

It was very amusing to see this lovely young girl, with great little car, being ABSOLUTELY clueless what RPMs are and how would she even use her paddle shifters. A bit sad if you ask me (and slightly horrifying perhaps, thinking how many others out there are just like that).

Just my $0.02 on the topic
Appreciate 2
      07-09-2015, 11:17 PM   #283
captainaudio
World's Foremost Authority
captainaudio's Avatar
United_States
1183
Rep
4,535
Posts

Drives: M4 Cab - Cayenne GTS - Jag XK
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Upper East Side Manhattan - Boca Raton FL - Lime Rock CT

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Bbb34
I find lots of people are confusing performance and driving "feel".

It really boils down to what you like.
If you love driving manual, it's very difficult to find replacement, and to me personally performance comes secondary. Satisfying feeling I personally get from driving manual, feeling of control, having to pay attention to what I'm doing all the time is very rewarding. So far I was unable to find experience that's as rewarding and satisfying with automatic transmission. Granted, lots of progress has been made, there are some trully amazing automatic transmissions out there. Better gas mileage, faster 0-60, up and down sifts that are quicker than ever thought possible. Still for those of us who love manuals, it's simply not the same.

My money will follow manual transmission, as difficult as this might be in the future. As long as I can find one, that's what I'm buying.

I'll just ask this though. Having recently driven with very young, new grad. co-worker in her first ever car, Golf GTI with automatic transmission.

Does anybody here think that young drivers would be that much better, initially and years down the road, if only they were forced to learn driving and obtain their license with manual transmission (as it was the case when I was "oh-so-young")???

It was very amusing to see this lovely young girl, with great little car, being ABSOLUTELY clueless what RPMs are and how would she even use her paddle shifters. A bit sad if you ask me (and slightly horrifying perhaps, thinking how many others out there are just like that).

Just my $0.02 on the topic
In the 1970s and 1980s there were millions of FWD Japanese econoboxes with Manual Transmissions on the road. I think it is somewhat unrealistic to conclude that everyone driving one was immersed in their driving and paying close attention. Granted many of the mediocre drivers who drove those MT cars then drive AT cars now but I seriously doubt that their driving was any better when they were driving MTs and a good case could be made that it may have been worse.

IMO if you need to be shifting gears to pay attention to driving you are just not a very good driver. On the type of road that is most conducive to not paying attention, long, boring, straight stretches of flat interstates, you can drive for very long periods without having to shift gears. On some roads like I75 in South Florida not only do you not have to shift you barely have to steer.

I agree with your observation that knowing how to drive an MT tends to lead to a better understanding of how to drive an AT in manual mode.

With the stability controls and anti-lock brakes in modern cars drivers don't have to learn the techniques of skid control or threshold braking that was necessary to control cars in the past. But the reality is that most drivers never learned those techniques anyway and in many cases their first experience with a skid or locked up brakes was just before they crashed,

As far as challenging and paying attention goes of all of the cars that I have owned perhaps the most challenging car to drive and the one that required the most attention was a beater 1962 Ford Falcon with skinny bias ply tires, a horrible floaty suspension, a pathetically underpowered engine, ridiculously slow steering and a god awful two speed Fordomatic transmission. Keeping up with traffic on highways and keeping the thing pointed where you wanted it to go was a constant challenge and took constant attention and was by no means "fun".

Last edited by captainaudio; 07-09-2015 at 11:51 PM..
Appreciate 0
      07-10-2015, 08:24 AM   #284
Bbb34
Major
Canada
731
Rep
1,472
Posts

Drives: '11 535i 6sp. DHP/RWD
Join Date: Jul 2014
Location: ON

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by captainaudio View Post
IMO if you need to be shifting gears to pay attention to driving you are just not a very good driver.
I didn't say "need" it's more of a "want". (oh, and I didn't take this personally, I'm pretty sure you didn't mean to say I'm not a good driver).

What I meant is that I feel more "in tune" with the car at all times with manual transmission. Daily as well as spirited driving is just different, you're approaching your turns and intersections differently, your climbs and descents, icy/snowy roads, passing other cars, you're just doing things differently. It all demands just a bit more care, your fundamental driving skills have to be developed first. In my opinion with manual transmission these skills are what makes you that much smoother, better and I'll even argue safer driver overall for everybody else on the road.

Quote:
Originally Posted by captainaudio View Post
I agree with your observation that knowing how to drive an MT tends to lead to a better understanding of how to drive an AT in manual mode.
For all the reasons I stated above, I'll just argue "better understanding of how to drive" and omit "AT in manual mode".

In your example you bring Florida and long stretches of boring highway as example and it's hard to disagree with that. What about other places, mountains, sometimes snow covered roads, two way traffic, cities that are not "flat" and have variable weather... etc?

There's never going to be universal agreement on this. I agree with most of what you said. I'm just trying to help manual side of debate and explain why personally I favor manual. But the bottom line is, we'll all spend money on what we like and car companies are going to build what sells.
Appreciate 0
      07-10-2015, 08:24 AM   #285
F83
Roofless & Ruthless
F83's Avatar
1356
Rep
1,480
Posts

Drives: 2015 AY 6MT F83
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: Seattle

iTrader: (1)

Garage List


Are we going to resolve this one once and for all? Impressive if we can.

Surprisingly for the Internet, people are talking past each other. 6MT gives what many believe to be a more immersive driving experience. The price of this is a bit of performance. The DCT gives maximum performance but perhaps with a bit less driver involvement. Given these trade offs, some prefer one over the other....

So what?
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Arcades

I blame Lups because of reasons.
Appreciate 2
      07-10-2015, 08:44 AM   #286
....,,,,..,,..
General
No_Country
6626
Rep
20,651
Posts

Drives: xxxx
Join Date: Dec 2013
Location: xxxx

iTrader: (0)

Quote:
Originally Posted by F83 View Post


Are we going to resolve this one once and for all? Impressive if we can.

Surprisingly for the Internet, people are talking past each other. 6MT gives what many believe to be a more immersive driving experience. The price of this is a bit of performance. The DCT gives maximum performance but perhaps with a bit less driver involvement. Given these trade offs, some prefer one over the other....

So what?

Very much doubt if it can be resolved, people have their own deep seated views.

One point though, I would actually say the 8AT as fitted to 3 series, gives more driver involvement.

For example.

Manual car, start it up, work through the gears or 2 to 5th etc depending on how you feel.
Go to over take drop it down x number of gears, complete the over take and back in to 5/6th gear.

That is the same every day, sun or shine.

With an 8AT.

Start the car up, in to drive, off you go.
One day you might keep it in comfort all day.
The next a mix of comfort and sport.
The next stick to the left and manual using the paddles.

Same over take move.
Options,
Keeping it in comfort, kick down and overtake.
Keep in comfort, drop a couple of gears using paddles.
Left shift in to sport and kick down
Left shift and drop a couple of gears using paddles and go in to full manual mode.
Complete over take, either back in to comfort and auto or keep in manual or sports auto for next move.


As mentioned previously 30 years of manual cars only and now a 3.0l 6 pot diesel with an 8AT gearbox.

While some of the manuals have been epic, the 8AT is another league again compared to your average auto.
Appreciate 0
Post Reply

Bookmarks


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:55 PM.




x3:
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
1Addicts.com, BIMMERPOST.com, E90Post.com, F30Post.com, M3Post.com, ZPost.com, 5Post.com, 6Post.com, 7Post.com, XBimmers.com logo and trademark are properties of BIMMERPOST