BMW's Start/Stop Button. A Good Thing or Fad?

Brookside · 04-15-2007, 08:22 PM

1) No. I hate the button. Give me my keys back.
2) Yes. No more keys.

Goodbye Car Keys.

Car Keys Could Go the Way of Tail Fins

Are we about to lose our car keys for good?

Some automobile manufacturers are offering up a replacement.

They can be found on about 55 cars and trucks, including luxury models from Audi, BMW and Mercedes, and on Nissan’s inexpensive Versa as part of a $700 “convenience package.” Push-button starters have also become standard on hybrid-electric vehicles, like the Toyota Prius.

James D. Farley, the chief of North American marketing at Toyota, said that he has been fretting about whether to build all future models with push-button starters.

“What keeps me awake?” he asked recently. “Car keys.”

Push-button starters are a retro feature, dating back to the industry’s toddler years. In 1913, the Locomobile became one of the first cars to use one. Carmakers also started using keys around that time, after ignitions (and car theft) were invented.

Today’s keyless models use a fob — the small remote control device that most modern cars use to lock and unlock doors — but it performs the additional duty of sending a signal to the ignition. For the car to start, the fob has to be somewhere near the dashboard, perhaps stowed in a cup holder.

A driver then just needs to put a foot on the brake, and push the button. The engine comes to life, or, in the case of hybrids, the word “ready” lights up on the dashboard. Turning off the car happens the same way: gearshift in park, foot on the brake, finger on the button.

Not everyone is quite ready to give up keys. Honda decided not to offer a push-button starter on its newest MDX model, sold by its Acura luxury division. The cost of installing sensors to operate the ignition, said its chief engineer, Frank Paluch, was more than Honda thought even well-heeled customers would be willing to pay.

But that may change as other car companies shift to push-buttons, sending car keys to the same bin now filled with window cranks and whitewall tires.

Link to Complete Story:http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/14/au...es&oref=slogin

Brookside · 04-16-2007, 07:33 AM

I've had a couple loaners from BMW with the push button start.
It's easy to master- put the fob in the slot, depress the brake and push the starter button. Nothing to it.
But it feels awkward- the fob going into the slot is very unassuring.."is it in there, do I push it in further?"
Bottom line...I hope this is a fad that goes away-give me my keys back!

spudw · 04-16-2007, 09:14 AM

I've never tried a push-button start, but I understand that Merc and other brands (Lexus?) don't require that the fob be inserted into a slot. Seems that the button requires a two-step process (at least in the BMW example), whereas the standard key is a one-motion affair. Were it just a matter of getting in and pushing a button, I'd be in favor. Also, what if you only want the elecricity on with no engine? What do you do then?

Brookside · 04-16-2007, 09:19 AM

I'm guessing ; but I think once the fob is in you can use the electric functions.

kway · 04-16-2007, 09:56 AM

I'm a fan of the starter button, but then I have a bit of a road racing background, so that's probably where it comes from. I agree with you, spud. I like the non-slot approach. Another option might be the fob itself becoming the button; insert fob, then push it past a detent to start the car.

spudw · 04-16-2007, 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brookside

I'm guessing ; but I think once the fob is in you can use the electric functions.

Makes sense. I guess if the battery in the fob fails (in 10 or 15 years) you're SOL...

They could also have made it so that you insert the fob, which would engage the battery, dash lights, fule pump, etc. and then push the fob to start the engine. Not as sexy as the button, but it would be a one-step process.

But inserting the fob and pushing it is probably, for marketing purposes, too similar to inserting a key and turning it.

We are shockingly simple creatures, aren't we...

Brookside · 04-16-2007, 02:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spudwest

We are shockingly simple creatures, aren't we...

Yes, and the older we get the more we like things to be routine...unfortunately.:biggrin:

135i_ · 08-15-2007, 01:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spudwest

I've never tried a push-button start, but I understand that Merc and other brands (Lexus?) don't require that the fob be inserted into a slot. Seems that the button requires a two-step process (at least in the BMW example), whereas the standard key is a one-motion affair. Were it just a matter of getting in and pushing a button, I'd be in favor. Also, what if you only want the elecricity on with no engine? What do you do then?

The way it works in Corvettes isn't too bad... The fob just has to be within 5 feet of the car and it'll start. So you can have it in your pocket and get in and start the car.

Nixon · 08-15-2007, 02:02 AM

I like the idea of push button starting too, but I didn't like the feel of putting the big fat fob in the dash in the 335xi I test drove. I prefered the Mercedes Benz I drove that had a Keyless Go SmartCard remote that fit in your wallet and you didn't have to take out. The Keyless Go was all RFID activated, so there was no need for a battery in the remote SmartCard

Maximus Decimus · 08-15-2007, 03:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spudwest

Makes sense. I guess if the battery in the fob fails (in 10 or 15 years) you're SOL...

I'm pretty sure it has a rechargeable battery and it charges when it is inserted if I remember correctly. I don't have the manual anymore. The 2 step process is a pain imo, but I guess it keeps the fob charged.

btw I voted for the key. Young guy, but just old school like that. Makes me feel more connected to the car. Don't know why, it just does.

inTgr8r · 08-15-2007, 07:33 AM

I don't mind the push button, but it's not a feature either.
I'm perfectly happy with using a key.

If I have to have the push button, it's the two step procedure that would bother me the most.

The one thing that I do like about it, is having just the fob to carry in my pocket.
I really don't like the BMW integrated fob/key with the key sticking out like a bayonet.
The unit that I had on my old Passat with the folding key blade was excellent.

ducati · 08-15-2007, 08:26 AM

I despise the stupid start button. We drove a few 3er's lately, and I was befuddled by why BMW would jump on the bandwagon: why add another motion to start and stop your car? Stick fob in hole, push, push start button. How is this any more intelligent than "stick key in ignition and twist?"

I suppose the true keyless (or shall we say, fobless?) system that BMW offers as an option wouldn't be too terribly bad.

I dunno, though, just give me a key. +1 to the VAG-style integrated plip/folding key, +/-0 to the fobless system, -1 to anything with a start button and the need to insert a separate fob.

Tijuana · 08-15-2007, 08:45 PM

I hate carrying any keys around. The sooner everything moves to voice or DNA, the better IMO. I can't wait until the day that my front door will be opened because it knows who I am, not because of a piece of metal I carry around.

USC2000 · 08-15-2007, 08:57 PM

No keys. I'd rather get in the car, bush a button, and go.

Vornado · 08-15-2007, 11:34 PM

I dont like the whole key fob process, but absolutely love comfort access. If it werent for comfort access, I'm sure it would be a pain and in that case I would prefer keys.

SCA · 08-15-2007, 11:56 PM

As the owner of an E90 it has grown on me, but I rather have a key w/ remote. Have we become so lazy we can no longer turn a key?

Oregon · 08-19-2007, 11:04 PM

What happens when you leave the Hot Wheels-lookin' thing in the car?

Cody

Maximus Decimus · 08-20-2007, 04:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tijuana

I hate carrying any keys around. The sooner everything moves to voice or DNA, the better IMO. I can't wait until the day that my front door will be opened because it knows who I am, not because of a piece of metal I carry around.

I hope I'm not the only one not looking forward to these days, but I guess it's just a sad matter of time. Soon we will be so isolated from everything. I love feeling connected to the car. I love the 'thunk' of bmw's doors, although that doesn't apply to the 7. But I'm about 60 years away from ever being interested in driving a car like that.

ducati · 08-20-2007, 08:21 AM

+1 Maximus. Personally, I don't need all the futz on modern cars. I don't like sunroofs, and on a coupe, who needs power windows? Auto climate control? Naah, I think I can manage myself.

If the intake and exhaust sound good (as they should) I rarely even use the stereo, so junk that, too.

A/C, though, that is one thing I like. It gets so hot and humid here in the US.

View Poll Results: Key or Starter Button? Which Do You Prefer?
No- Give me my car keys back.	9	20.00%
Yes- Out with keys, in with the starter button.	36	80.00%
Voters: 45. You may not vote on this poll

04-15-2007, 08:22 PM	#1
Brookside Major 257 Rep 1,136 Posts Drives: 2016 228i M-Sport Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: KCMO iTrader: (0)	BMW's Start/Stop Button. A Good Thing or Fad? 1) No. I hate the button. Give me my keys back. 2) Yes. No more keys. Goodbye Car Keys. Car Keys Could Go the Way of Tail Fins Are we about to lose our car keys for good? Some automobile manufacturers are offering up a replacement. They can be found on about 55 cars and trucks, including luxury models from Audi, BMW and Mercedes, and on Nissan’s inexpensive Versa as part of a $700 “convenience package.” Push-button starters have also become standard on hybrid-electric vehicles, like the Toyota Prius. James D. Farley, the chief of North American marketing at Toyota, said that he has been fretting about whether to build all future models with push-button starters. “What keeps me awake?” he asked recently. “Car keys.” Push-button starters are a retro feature, dating back to the industry’s toddler years. In 1913, the Locomobile became one of the first cars to use one. Carmakers also started using keys around that time, after ignitions (and car theft) were invented. Today’s keyless models use a fob — the small remote control device that most modern cars use to lock and unlock doors — but it performs the additional duty of sending a signal to the ignition. For the car to start, the fob has to be somewhere near the dashboard, perhaps stowed in a cup holder. A driver then just needs to put a foot on the brake, and push the button. The engine comes to life, or, in the case of hybrids, the word “ready” lights up on the dashboard. Turning off the car happens the same way: gearshift in park, foot on the brake, finger on the button. Not everyone is quite ready to give up keys. Honda decided not to offer a push-button starter on its newest MDX model, sold by its Acura luxury division. The cost of installing sensors to operate the ignition, said its chief engineer, Frank Paluch, was more than Honda thought even well-heeled customers would be willing to pay. But that may change as other car companies shift to push-buttons, sending car keys to the same bin now filled with window cranks and whitewall tires. Link to Complete Story:http://www.nytimes.com/2007/04/14/au...es&oref=slogin
	Appreciate 0 Tweet Quote

04-16-2007, 07:33 AM	#2
Brookside Major 257 Rep 1,136 Posts Drives: 2016 228i M-Sport Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: KCMO iTrader: (0)	I've had a couple loaners from BMW with the push button start. It's easy to master- put the fob in the slot, depress the brake and push the starter button. Nothing to it. But it feels awkward- the fob going into the slot is very unassuring.."is it in there, do I push it in further?" Bottom line...I hope this is a fad that goes away-give me my keys back!
	Appreciate 0 Quote

04-16-2007, 09:14 AM	#3
spudw Major 125 Rep 1,305 Posts Drives: 2009 128i Join Date: Jul 2006 Location: Ottawa iTrader: (0)	I've never tried a push-button start, but I understand that Merc and other brands (Lexus?) don't require that the fob be inserted into a slot. Seems that the button requires a two-step process (at least in the BMW example), whereas the standard key is a one-motion affair. Were it just a matter of getting in and pushing a button, I'd be in favor. Also, what if you only want the elecricity on with no engine? What do you do then?
	Appreciate 0 Quote

04-16-2007, 09:19 AM	#4
Brookside Major 257 Rep 1,136 Posts Drives: 2016 228i M-Sport Join Date: Jan 2007 Location: KCMO iTrader: (0)	I'm guessing ; but I think once the fob is in you can use the electric functions.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

04-16-2007, 09:56 AM	#5
kway BMW CCA# 144245 7 Rep 35 Posts Drives: Join Date: Dec 2006 iTrader: (0)	I'm a fan of the starter button, but then I have a bit of a road racing background, so that's probably where it comes from. I agree with you, spud. I like the non-slot approach. Another option might be the fob itself becoming the button; insert fob, then push it past a detent to start the car.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 02:02 AM	#9
Nixon Banned 58 Rep 1,396 Posts Drives: : Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: : iTrader: (0)	I like the idea of push button starting too, but I didn't like the feel of putting the big fat fob in the dash in the 335xi I test drove. I prefered the Mercedes Benz I drove that had a Keyless Go SmartCard remote that fit in your wallet and you didn't have to take out. The Keyless Go was all RFID activated, so there was no need for a battery in the remote SmartCard
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 07:33 AM	#11
inTgr8r Lieutenant General 2455 Rep 11,667 Posts Drives: M2 Comp Join Date: Mar 2006 Location: Toronto iTrader: (10)	I don't mind the push button, but it's not a feature either. I'm perfectly happy with using a key. If I have to have the push button, it's the two step procedure that would bother me the most. The one thing that I do like about it, is having just the fob to carry in my pocket. I really don't like the BMW integrated fob/key with the key sticking out like a bayonet. The unit that I had on my old Passat with the folding key blade was excellent. __________________ '21 M2C Hockenheim Silver '18 718 Cayman S Lava Orange (sold) '13 E92 M3 Santorini Blue (sold) '07 Z4 M Coupe Alpine White (sold)
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 08:26 AM	#12
ducati First Lieutenant 11 Rep 394 Posts Drives: Join Date: Aug 2007 iTrader: (0)	I despise the stupid start button. We drove a few 3er's lately, and I was befuddled by why BMW would jump on the bandwagon: why add another motion to start and stop your car? Stick fob in hole, push, push start button. How is this any more intelligent than "stick key in ignition and twist?" I suppose the true keyless (or shall we say, fobless?) system that BMW offers as an option wouldn't be too terribly bad. I dunno, though, just give me a key. +1 to the VAG-style integrated plip/folding key, +/-0 to the fobless system, -1 to anything with a start button and the need to insert a separate fob.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 08:45 PM	#13
Tijuana Second Lieutenant 5 Rep 217 Posts Drives: 535xi Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Indianapolis iTrader: (0)	I hate carrying any keys around. The sooner everything moves to voice or DNA, the better IMO. I can't wait until the day that my front door will be opened because it knows who I am, not because of a piece of metal I carry around.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 08:57 PM	#14
USC2000 Lieutenant Colonel 127 Rep 1,603 Posts Drives: F30 328i M Sport Join Date: Jul 2007 Location: El Paso, TX iTrader: (10)	No keys. I'd rather get in the car, bush a button, and go.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 11:34 PM	#15
Vornado A swell fellow 3 Rep 146 Posts Drives: Hot air balloon Join Date: Feb 2007 Location: Texas iTrader: (0)	I dont like the whole key fob process, but absolutely love comfort access. If it werent for comfort access, I'm sure it would be a pain and in that case I would prefer keys.
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-15-2007, 11:56 PM	#16
SCA Brigadier General 585 Rep 3,752 Posts Drives: Multiple BMWs Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: 🇺🇸 iTrader: (0)	As the owner of an E90 it has grown on me, but I rather have a key w/ remote. Have we become so lazy we can no longer turn a key?
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-19-2007, 11:04 PM	#17
Oregon NRA Life Member, BMW CCA 30 year member 213 Rep 2,614 Posts Drives: 04' M3 Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: Oregon iTrader: (1) Garage List 1971 2002 [0.00] 2004 M3 [0.00] 2008 135i [0.00]	What happens when you leave the Hot Wheels-lookin' thing in the car? Cody
	Appreciate 0 Quote

08-20-2007, 08:21 AM	#19
ducati First Lieutenant 11 Rep 394 Posts Drives: Join Date: Aug 2007 iTrader: (0)	+1 Maximus. Personally, I don't need all the futz on modern cars. I don't like sunroofs, and on a coupe, who needs power windows? Auto climate control? Naah, I think I can manage myself. If the intake and exhaust sound good (as they should) I rarely even use the stereo, so junk that, too. A/C, though, that is one thing I like. It gets so hot and humid here in the US.
	Appreciate 0 Quote